The Physics Puzzler

You are in a glass elevator traveling upward with constant speed. You lift a box from the elevator floor up to your waist. The elevator moves a distance d during this time. From your point of view, you have done work = mgh where h = the height of your waist from the elevator floor.

But a stationary observer outside the elevator sees the box move through a distance h + d since the elevator move a distance d while you lifted it. The stationary observer claims the work done is mg(h+d).

Is this a contradiction or not? What is the source of the extra mgd work claimed by the stationary observer?



Be sure to enter your full name. Enter your email address ONLY if you want the number of points awarded e-mailed to you. Responses should be brief but complete. You must click the SUBMIT button to submit your entry. Entries are due by noon on Monday of next week.

Full Name:
Email Address

Response(s):

....